Search

What concepts, ideas and examples from this text contribute to the theory and practice of archive ethnography? The idea that data curation practices are “performative” (p. 156) is an important consideration for the data collection and curation practices for both archive ethnography and social science research in general. As Mauthner & Gardos (2015) write, “Data curation practices are ‘performative’ in that they help bring into being the data they ostensibly preserve” (p. 156).

What is the main argument, narrative, or e/affectThe authors argue that the making of an archive is an act of power, which influences the structure and content of the archive—data—itself. According to Mauthner & Gardos (2015), “Data curation and archival practices… can be understood as historically—and culturally—specific and contingent ‘metaphysical practices that necessarily enact specific metaphysical commitments to the exclusion of others’” (p. 156). By this they mean that archives consist of both the processes of memory-making and forgetting.

The article builds on the work of Derrida and Foucault to argue that data curation practices in social science quantitative research data are not merely neutral techniques but are perfomative as in these practices are constitutive of the very data that is being preserved.

The article provides a number of philosophical insights on how we are anthropologists should engage with archives and the prevailing practices that continue to this day. Drawing from Derrida's Archive Fever, the authors push forward the post modern mission to take on archives, the archivists and the process of archiving itself as objects of study, complicating their understanding as being constitutive of the very 'past' and 'memory' that they seek to preserve.