Skip to main content

Search

Fu Yu Chang annotation

It puts a lot of emphasis on the relation between toxicity, lower income communities, racism and putting these groups of people who are already vulnerable in even more vulnerable situations.  Seems like a safe place is also a privilege and not a right as it should be.

Fu Yu Chang Annotation

It’s an analytic map that shows the distribution of people by income.  It is a great and easy way to show with clarity the differences in a city and how communities are put together. It can be used for different means, especially for city projects and planning.  I believe this single tool can be used as an excuse for all kinds of interventions: positive and negative. 

TurnbullJonathon VtP Annotation: How does this visualization (including caption) advance ethnographic insight?

The visualisation and caption reveal how toxics are unequally distributed in urban spaces according to racial geographies of segregation. It hows how environmental risks disproportionately affect people living in Austin based on a racial geography dating back to the early 20th century.

TurnbullJonathon VtP Annotation: Can you suggest ways to elaborate the caption of this visualization?

The caption of this image is very detailed and explains well the visualisation. It draws attention to the history of the area and how this plays into the ways in which people experience toxicity today. I think it explains everything well. I would, however, tend to avoid referencing in captions like this. Could the point be made without having to reference other people's work like this?

TurnbullJonathon VtP Annotation: Can you suggest ways to enrich this image to extend its ethnographic import?

The image and caption are excellent visual representations of the issue at hand. However, it could be improved if I am being picky. For example, the yellow writing is a bit jarring. I wonder if the colours could be tweaked to make it more presentable, unless they were chosen for a specific reason. Again, a picky comment. The overall artificat is brilliant.

TurnbullJonathon VtP Annotation: What does this visualization (including caption) say about toxics?

The image and caption document well how toxics and environmental risks have specific histories and will have specific situated futures according to the political and cultural economy of the area in which they are materially found. The caption explains this at great length with reference to Austin.